A U S T R A L I A N G O U R M E T P A G E S

Pinot Challenge 2004

The Judges:

John Atwill

Roberta Muir

Tim Pak Poy

Sharon Wild

Huon Hooke

Tom Neal Tacker

Jon Osbeiston

John Cunnington

Matthew Evans

Christopher Morrison

Franz Scheurer (no vote)

Dr. Max Lake

The Wines:

No	Wine	Vintage
1	Providence Miguet Reserve	2002
2	Holm Oak Vineyards	2002
3	Carlei Estate	2000
4	Hurley Vineyard	2001
5	Elgee Park Baillieu Myer Family Reserve	2001
6	Di Stasio Coldstream	2001
7	Ashton Hills	2002
8	Penfolds Cellar Reserve	2001
9	Labyrinth Viggers Vineyard	2002
10	Giaconda	2001
11	Domaine A Reserve du Patron	2000
12	Curly Flat	2000

The Scores

Without Food

Judges	1	2	3	4	5	6	7	8	9	10	11	12
John Atwill	8	5	11	4	10	12	7	6	1	2	9	3
John Cunnington	8	11	1	5	4	12	9	6	7	10	2	3
Matthew Evans	7	10	11	5	8	9	12	1	3	2	6	4
Huon Hooke	11	5	7	8	9	12	4	10	1	2	6	3
Dr. Max Lake	12	9	11	3	10	8	7	2	6	4	1	5
Christopher Morrison	9	7	2	8	11	12	3	1	10	6	4	5
Roberta Muir	4	2	1	3	11	10	7	8	5	12	9	6
Jon Osbeiston	7	3	4	6	10	9	8	12	1	11	2	5
Tim Pak Poy	8	5	2	1	6	12	10	9	11	3	7	4
Franz Scheurer (no vote)
Tom N. Tacker	11	5	1	2	9	12	6	10	8	3	4	7
Sharon Wild	6	9	4	7	10	12	1	5	3	2	8	11
TOTAL	91	71	55	52	98	120	74	70	56	57	58	56

With Food:

Judges	1	2	3	4	5	6	7	8	9	10	11	12
John Atwill	9	11	7	4	10	12	6	5	1	2	8	3
John Cunnington	8	11	1	4	5	12	10	7	6	9	3	2
Matthew Evans	9	8	7	11	6	10	12	1	3	5	4	2
Huon Hooke	9	6	3	12	8